Bed Buddy Reporting On: Puffy Original Mattress2019-02-26T21:33:19+00:00

Project Description

Bed Buddy Reporting On: Puffy Original Mattress

Our research includes a 100 consecutive sleep test, so we can say, ‘YUP, this is what we found, because we really slept on it!’

All the details

FIRMNESS 5 (‘Medium’)
Durability 2 – The Puffy mattress uses slightly less dense foams which should be durable for lighter sleepers but won’t last as long for heavier sleepers (230lbs+) with nightly use.
Motion Isolation 5 – The Puffy mattress isolates motion very well making it a good option for couples or easily disturbed sleepers
Off-gassing 3 – The Puffy has some potential for off-gassing which should dissipate within a few days of unboxing
Conforming 4 – The Puffy mattress conforms closely to sleepers which can alleviate pressure points and gives the sleeper the feeling of sleeping “in” and not “on” the mattress.
Sex 2 – The Puffy is a very conforming memory foam mattress making it less “bouncy” (responsive) so less ideal for sex compared to other mattress types
Temperature Neutrality 2 – The Puffy mattress is fair in this category which is on par with similarly constructed memory foam mattresses
Edge Support 2 – The Puffy has fair edge support which puts it on par with similarly constructed memory foam mattresses
Noise 5 – The Puffy mattress will be silent when bearing weight so noise isn’t a concern.
Light side sleeper under 130 LBS 4
Average side sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 3
Heavy side sleeper over 230 LBS 2
Light back sleeper under 130 LBS 3
Average back sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 3
Heavy back sleeper over 230 LBS 2
Light stomach sleeper under 130 LBS 3
Average stomach sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 3
Heavy stomach sleeper over 230 LBS 2
Firmness Rating 5 (‘Medium’)
Thickness 10”
Support Core Components 6″ 1.5 PCF HD Polyfoam
Comfort Layer Components 4″ 2.5 PCF Gel Memory Foam
Cover Components 100% Polyester
Twin 38W” x 75L” x 10”
Twin Extra Long (XL) 38W” x 80L” x 10”
Full 54W” x 75L” x 10”
Queen 60W” x 80L” x 10”
King 76W” x 80L” x 10”
California King 72W” x 84L” x 10”
Twin $625
Twin Extra Long (XL) $675
Full $800
Queen $950
King $1,150
California King $1,150
Sleep trial 101 Nights
Refund Full
Warranty Lifetime Non-Prorated
Warranty Transfer Non-Transferable
Delivery Puffy mattresses are compressed, vacuum sealed, and boxed for shipping
Availability Puffy ships mattresses anywhere in the United States and Canada.
White Glove Delivery Not Available
Old Mattress Removal Not Available
Customer Service 8 out of 10 owner experiences show customers have had a positive experience with Puffy, irrespective of whether or not they liked their mattress.
Company History Puffy was launched in 2017
BBB Rating A
Physical Stores Puffy does not operate any brick-and-mortar locations.
Phone 1-800-430-8380

Bed Buddy Report | Verdict |

  • Motion transfer and conforming were major benefits
  • Softer foams used to make Puffy mattresses a great option for lighter and average weight sleepers


  • 101-night sleep trial period and no minimum break-in period
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • Lifetime warranty with exclusively non-prorated coverage.
  • Uniquely conforming construction
  • Free delivery
  • #jumpforkids charity program that donates mattresses to children in need


  • Weak edge support
  • Only one firmness option available per model

Bed Buddy Report |Findings |

The puffy is a single firmness, two-layer memory foam mattress that stands 10″ tall and has a polyfoam support core. My review of the Puffy mattress found that motion transfer and conforming were major benefits. I also found that the softer foams used make Puffy mattresses a great option for lighter and average weight sleepers.


What Type of Sleeper Is Best Suited for a Puffy Mattress? 

Based on my customer feedback, the Puffy Mattresses have received the following grades among sleepers of different weights and preferred sleep positions. Please note that these ratings are subjective and that everyone has varying experiences on different mattresses. Sleeper comfort and spinal support are the most important factors when it comes to selecting a mattress.

As you can see, the Puffy is a solid choice for side sleepers and for light to average sleepers. I am wary of recommending the mattress to heavier weight sleepers as the softer foams likely won’t offer the support they need.

For more information on sleeping positions please see my guides for side, back, stomach and combination sleepers.


My testing process found that Puffy mattresses should also be great for you if… 

  • You love the feel of memory foam – sleeping more “in” than “on” a bed.
  • Are a sleeper that weights less than 230lbs.
  • You sleep with a partner and are easily disturbed.

We’re your Bed Buddy!!

Our mission is a simple one: We want to help you get incredible sleep, like a good sleep buddy should. And how you might ask? By not only conducting extensive research into the subject itself, but by personally testing out the thousands of mattresses on the market that claim to improve the quality of your slumber.

We really sleep on our mattress research by testing each for at least a hundred sleeps! We do not just compare features like review blogs, nor collate others’ online reviews, nor do a brief test of one to seven nights. No, our research includes a one hundred consecutive sleep test, so we can say, ‘Yup, this is what we found, because we really slept on it!’

We have no affiliation with the companies we feature, and any advertisements that appear on this website not at our discretion. They are there to keep the slumber party going. The Bed Buddy team takes incredible pride in the work we do. We hope that the reviews, news, and sleep information can help you on your personal journey for better sleep. And the job is fun – it’s not all naps! … sometimes… We love creating content that you enjoy, whether it’s on our site, or our newsletter, which you should sign up for.